Regional/Topical

How should we organize a geography class?6th-regional-or-topical

Some people seem to think
that it is crucially important
to make an early decision
about how to organize a class.

Should the units be organized
regionally, or topically:

Regional – Africa, Europe, South Asia, etc.

Topical – environment, population, economy, etc.

We suggest that the overall organization of a course
does not matter very much, because

if you organize a class topically,
you have to include regional examples,
or it’s “just science, not geography”

and

if you organize the class regionally,
you have to add topical explanations,
or it’s “just a packet of postcards”

Here are some draft materials to support a discussion about course organization –

For convenience, this website is organized regionally –
but after we have “populated” it with activities,
presentations, and other teaching materials,
we will offer at least three pacing diagrams:

regional class schedule will have
just a short introductory unit
to provide global context.

topical class schedule will use big themes
such as environment, population, culture,
movement/trade, and conflict.

blended class schedule will focus on big themes
for the first 6-8 weeks, followed by a regional
“tour of the world” to extend the examples,
and then a capstone activity or two
for the last 4-6 weeks.